The Short list

You need to be logged in to get access to the forums. You can do so here

Author Responses

Member

Posted by Sillvan Denote

Friday 21 August 2009 11:08:29 am

Well, after an exiting run I woke this morning to have a look at the announced short list of contenders and runners up’s. I don’t think there are words enough to express my surprise at the absolute lack of anything remotely close to originality, business viability or something resembling sensibility in 90% of the ideas short-listed today. All I can say to myself is that this is run via a television network and I most certainly should have know better than to expect sense to be at the forefront of such competitions.

With that said I do hope that in the future someone or some entity will run a similar event for the generation of innovation, creativity and viable ideas that just might make our world a better place to live in today

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Florin Hanganu

Friday 21 August 2009 11:40:57 am

As minimal courtesy to those contenders who really took this competition seriously and spent time and energy to come up with a really good idea, CNBC should give us the rationale behind each project on the shortlist.

This list makes you really question your basic communication and understanding skills. It looks like some hundred people together with their partners suffered some sort of mass delusion and they entered the wrong competition with the wrong project.

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by vivian balke

Friday 21 August 2009 11:49:48 am

Maybe I have a different understanding of NEW ideas or ENTREPRENEURSHIP, but to me the short list is quite a surprise too. Particular business is existing since years. Business sense, quality, originality and popularity of the ideas in this competition seem to have no influence. On some of the ideas shortlisted no one bothered to comment.

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by ralph coster

Friday 21 August 2009 11:57:14 am

Dear team, interesting choices. As professional and green investor, I would definitively not put my money in these concepts. Wonder, what kind of audience CNBC is targeting.
Best, Ralph

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by eisi haraldsson

Friday 21 August 2009 12:08:09 pm

Having seen the short list, I must admit that I am surprised. I would have put my money on ideas that were designed to help the environment be profitable, somewhat original and definately easy to market.

Now I am wondering if this was a real competetion or just a road show.

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Florin Hanganu

Friday 21 August 2009 12:14:40 pm

To summarize what happened:

The cow gave birth to a fat beautiful calf; the problem was that the calf was born dead.

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Gisli Njalsson

Friday 21 August 2009 12:48:05 pm

I think it is very clear what happens when the marketing monster that today’s society has created leaves dock to destinations unknown. I would assume that too actually change the world for a better place or too make a difference in, for or around the status quo one would need to light a fire under our understanding and definition of what we tend to call society.

 Alert moderator

Entrant

Posted by Alfred Wimmer

Friday 21 August 2009 3:10:04 pm

I participate in architects competitions. The competition's quality depends primarily on the jury, which simple FAILED.
To the sponsors address,
yes, I will notify the professional representations about this competition
to inform their members that this competition of CNBC and Alliance promisses
more then it can deliver.

Alfred Wimmer
MAA/ARCH/CE/MBA

 Alert moderator

Entrant

Posted by Alex Hanganu

Friday 21 August 2009 4:12:38 pm

All entries than even hinted to have a significant climate change impact, those that touched taboo subjects like geoengineering (mitigation through biosphere carbon cycle management, like biochar) were ignored. Why?

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Iris Merwin

Friday 21 August 2009 4:54:18 pm

This is an eyeopener showing how marketing ploys are used to mislead the public. It would be interesting to hear the final result. Somehow I have the feeling that the winner, which idea is the reason for this competition road show, will promote and market his idea as a viable investment since it was elected the best of 2009. If the Good Entrepreneur is running this as a scam, then of course we can understand the selection. Nothing else makes more sense. All you have to do is to read the entries that dont even have one comment between them. There are quite many good ideas that should have been on the list but then......

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Nitin Kapoor

Friday 21 August 2009 6:09:46 pm

CNBC- you have underwhelmed us!

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by

Moderated by: Administrator User

Sunday 23 August 2009 2:33:09 am

This post has been deleted by the Administrators due to the use of politically insenstive terms.
---

The Good Entrepeneur Team

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by

Moderated by: Administrator User

Sunday 23 August 2009 2:45:39 am

This post has been deleted by the Administrators due to the use of politically insenstive terms.
---

The Good Entrepeneur Team

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by henry knapp

Sunday 23 August 2009 8:31:58 am

I totally agree that free bicycles (I have seen this approach 5 years ago and you get a bike for 5 USD on every flee market) and recycled hand bags will change our world, don't you?

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by

Tuesday 25 August 2009 10:57:24 pm

what politically insensitive terms was that??? I just told the truth that the judges were likely so incompetent that they just looked among those that were voted highest and when they had picked 10 through no particularly intelligent process they stopped looking. so they missed those brilliant participants who petty competitors have voted down.
if you look at the ratings of the 10 selected you will see this theory is dreadfully likely to be true. such amazing incompetence and indifference.
as a result they chose one who makes handbags out of used firehoses instead of a car that uses 20 times less energy than typical small cars http://www.goodentrepreneur.com/T...easy-quick-freedom-from-fossil-fuels. A complete fluff project was chosen over one that could actually change the world. And so are many of the 10 chosen. Not one with a chance to make a real difference.

it is a travesty of indifference and incompetence, one that I sadly predicted with significant certainty.
I'm sure this post will be deleted as well using whatever lie that comes to their minds to hide from the truth.

 Alert moderator

Entrant

Posted by Nigel Jarman

Friday 28 August 2009 6:45:07 pm

> they just looked among those that were voted highest

A quick look at the stats shows this not to be true, the mayor choices was from the middle of the popular lot, with a few from the front and less from the back.

 Alert moderator

Member

Posted by Thor Derro

Tuesday 01 September 2009 9:10:29 pm

Today you are looking at a re-generation of old perceptions, old views and a few realistic innovative ideas, you can take a political view, a conservative one or a radical one, however nothing will change the fact that as we continue to develop our technological capability our general mass mentality seems to slide or indeed seems to simply stay in place.

It always seems a bit strange how our bearing coasts towards another gadget or another sociological solution. I really do wonder when it will become fashionable or indeed a correct term both for the institutions on this planet or people as a whole to seek which is ours by right of birth.

I speak simply of a thing we all use on a daily basis, a thing that inspires not to mention a mechanism that can confound ourselves. Seeking this thing we like to call innovation, we continually ask ourselves “Can I make money?” In another world, in another place people would look at our behavior in a different light.

Granted in our society Cash is king, but as increasing awareness arises from our selves, it will become increasingly difficult for the greater corporations in this world to do business simply for the fact of fashionable marketing terms like “Green”

All things considered I implore the intellectual community to tackle the true beast, an animal that has been long in waiting, mainly ourselves. Too be more Intelligent, capacity, cognitive, emotion, memory too name a few.

 Alert moderator

Entrant

Posted by Alex Hanganu

Wednesday 02 September 2009 10:10:20 pm

No finalists today ... the debate is hot, all short-listed entries are so strong nothing separates them, impossible to decide ... contest abandoned.

 Alert moderator

Rating:
  • Currently 3/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry

by Karim Jaroudi
any info about leather tanners in Kazak?

by Looney Barameda
Hey dexter, I like the generator in...

by FishBowl Inafishbowl
Inafishbowl.com founder and entrepren...

REGISTER NOW to contribute to discussions

Rating:
  • Currently 3/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Anne-Kathrin Kuhl...
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 2.5/5 Stars.
View entry
Rating:
  • Currently 3/5 Stars.
View entry
Markus count Matu...
Rating:
  • Currently 3/5 Stars.
View entry
Sandeep Manohar N...
Rating:
  • Currently 3/5 Stars.
View entry